Wir

Kann es sein, dass diese Sache der Autor vom brillanten Film Get Out - Rette deine Haut gemacht hat?! Dieser Versuch um einen Horrorfilm mit irgendwelcher (vielleicht philosophischen?!) Überlappung funktioniert in keiner Hinsicht. Technisch gesehen befindet er sich an der Hollywood-Spitze, aber der Inhalt ist lächerlich und man muss über ihn nur ungläubig den Kopf schütteln. Szenen, welche die Zuschauer*innen erschrecken sollen, wirken verlegen und manchmal sogar lächerlich. Dialoge, die cool sein möchten, klingen unnatürlich und dumm. Bei der Enthüllung des Geheimnisses spürt man den Versuch um einen interessanten Existenz-Untergrund. Der entpuppt sich aber auch als ein WTF-Unsinn. Es sieht so aus, als ob man hier auf die Geige von Shyamalans Morgenoriginalität oder der Originalität der Themen von Stephen King spielen wollte. Das Talent reichte aber nur für ein Kinderukulele mit der Hälfte der Saiten. (16.10.2020)

An overly calculated and sure-footed Oscar-winning film that ticks off the likely situations to come, and they do come, including the pathetic ending. But the dialogues between Tony and Shirley are hilariously written, there's a great spark between them and I laughed my heart out at times. Viggo plays my peer, always eating like me, getting a pot belly like me, just cute. I'd like him to win an Oscar, more than Rami "look-at-my-brutal-attempt" Malek, and more than Ali, who to me is an actor of one expression. (30.07.2019)

For the first three quarters, the second film of Jordan Peele gave me a “fuller” horror experience than his début Get Out. It has first-rate craftsmanship, a brilliant premise, excellent performances led by Lupita Nyongo, and the humour is better incorporated and not intruding. Us was about to get an enthusiastic five-star rating, especially with the social overlap about some kind of uprising of those less fortunate than us being very topical, but unfortunately, it derails by the end. The closing mythological explanation either shouldn’t have been there (so that the doubles worked on a purely allegorical level), or it should have been more bulletproof, because the way it’s presented makes you poke into several practical details of the working of the world of the doubles, which is a road to hell. And the very last twist is even more confusing. Immediately after the screening, I’m not sure whether it didn’t unintendedly make the film lose its meaning. At the same time, I’m looking forward to watching it again in the future and, already knowing the twists, see if it makes sense or not. In any case, Us does provide plenty of material for an “autopsy” and I’m sure it’ll remain in my head for awhile, which is appreciated. (26.03.2019)

Peele hat schrecklich spekuliert. Er hat sich darum bemüht, eine nächste organische Mischung aus einem Horrorfilm, einer Komödie und einer sozialen Metapher zu schaffen… Das, was dabei entstanden ist, kann man aber als abgearbeiteten und inkohärenten Mischmasch bezeichnen. (29.03.2019)

I can´t shake the feeling that Peele originally intended it to be a pilot episode of Sterling's cult (and crucial for “peripheral" genres) The Twilight Zone, which will be soon reincarnated. And it would have made a fantastic pilot which would have proven that Peele can pay tributes to the models/originals, keep the spirit and ideas of the original and still make the movie up to date and specific in his unique manner. But it should have been a pilot with a 60-minute footage, not a two-hour movie. Even though Peele is such a good director and has really actors at hand, the essence is so high-quality (it works both as a relaxed genre movie and as a satire) and on top of that, he can take advantage of brilliant Abels and he is not afraid to use him properly, so you won´t be become bored of it, not for a moment. In fact, you will feel quite the opposite. However, I cannot get rid of the feeling that it is an “excellent short story but slightly worse feature film". (26.03.2019)

Jordan Peele is undoubtedly a huge talent, which he has shown not only in his comedy sketches, but also with his hit Get Out, and high hopes were pinned on Us, based on the amazing trailer and positive reactions from critics. In the end feelings are slightly mixed, the film will definitely once again divide audiences into two camps, similar to Mother or Hereditary. Mainstream viewers and teens can stay home, this is a much more challenging spectacle than it first appears and those expecting a classic home invasion, slasher or horror will be sorely disappointed. The biggest trump cards are definitely the actors, with Lupita Nyong'o giving an extraordinary double performance, the superb craftsmanship, the details, the camera shots, the visuals and the intense music (“I Got 5 on It” is played three times and is quite goosebump-inducing during the final scene), and the very disarming and effective twists and turns, which you may not understand right away, but the creativity cannot be denied. Us also works in terms of horror. The home invasion is filmed in a decently atmospheric manner and the slasher rampage is quite brutal, though unfortunately, there is no explicit gore. In places the film is underpinned by comedy interludes, which work for the most part. It's slightly disappointing that the film isn't downright creepy and there's a distinct lack of a memorable scene to talk about in the future. Many may also be bothered by the fact that some issues aren't put squarely on the table, and whether the whole thing even makes sense is also debatable. I will definitely give this a re-watch and even though I was expecting grittier and more dense stuff, I still have to admit that there hasn't been a horror film this original and creative in years. 80%. (22.03.2019)

For however much Jordan Peele is following the overrated Get Out with a film that divides the audience and for which I could easily understand any choice on the rating scale, this is a surprise that caught me quite unprepared. And that I more than anyone else would be the one praising this film the most? I would never believe it. But Us is a true example of a combination of nerve-wracking situations, goosebump-inducing moments, and humor that doesn't play it safe and instead complements the mood excellently, in most cases, in a completely unforced way. The social issues are present this time are just right, and also subtle, so you need to (voluntarily?) dig into them in your own way and not get slapped in the face with them every few minutes, as was the case with Get Out. The first reveal pleasantly surprised me in how it doesn't hold back in terms of genre, the second, which some found excessive and degrading, actually spun the ideological whirlwind at double speed for me. I might even leave the fifth star for a hypothetical second viewing due to the occasional brutality and overall despair. Although I felt very claustrophobic almost the entire two hours while watching, the battle in the background with the pas de deux composition is an unprecedented example of harmony between music and image that I will want to see again. A sculpted toy that can't be faulted. (27.03.2019)

With this grotesquely warped horror movie reminiscent of The Twilight Zone, Jordan Peele has confirmed his position as an illustrious talent in the field of genre films. In Us, those who are so inclined can see a provocative parallel to the basic principle of capitalism, i.e. the presumed right to privilege and living life at the expense of someone else, which brings out the dark side of people. At the same time, however, it is simply a great, original horror flick that is not satisfied with the superficial tricks with which most current contributions to the genre are inundated. (01.04.2019)

It goes by quickly without getting boring, Peele delivers a very original concept that plays with our expectations, but unfortunately, this incomprehensible genre hodgepodge can’t never fully satisfy its ambitions of social comedy-horror. Get Out was solidly built on paranoia and the humour worked like an almost welcome relief, Us is packed with ideas, jokes and wannabe shocking twists, but it doesn’t give the viewer a chance to comfortably get into the story and enjoy the concept or feel scared. And no, I don’t think the experience can improve with a rewatch. 60% (03.04.2019)

Jordan Peele schiebt sich in die Position eines Leaders origineller Horrorstreifen, denen auch ein humoriges Element nicht fehlt (was ich sehr schätze). Er hat zwei gelungene Streifen geschrieben und gedreht, von denen Get Out doch mehr punktete. Doch bei Wir schätze ich die Idee, die Kreativität und die abschließende Pointe. Darüber hinaus erfordert die Geschichte von den Schauspielern eine stärkere Leistung als üblich. Ein intelligentes Horrorvergnügen. (07.06.2019)

After the fame-fair, the sanctimony, the back-slapping, the accolades, and the paternalistic labeling as "Black Hitchcock" (or later, more appropriately, "the first Peele"), one might have expected that this filmmaker's next script would simply be overdeveloped. There's a very strong sense of the thorough research into the horror genre that Peele had clearly done before. This is noticeable here not only in the references and quotations, which are thankfully sparse, but especially in the structure and formal elements. The immobilization of the head of the family right at the beginning is borrowed from Funny Games (here, however, via a baseball bat instead of a golf club, which does make a mess later in the film), the threat of tailor's scissors from the French Inside, work with a second plan ala It Follows, evil sealed in underground tunnels, see for example, Barker's The Midnight Meat Train, and the home invasion genre that climbs from the surface of a single house to somewhere beyond the metaphysical framework brings to mind, again, the French Martyrs. These reminders of the New French Extreme period specifically are what do Us the greatest disservice, because like in Get Out, there is a reluctance to work with violence, which is, however, one of the essential ingredients of the HI thriller. Imagining how the blood would have flowed off the screen during the scene of the families being slaughtered in the second house if it had been filmed in France sometime around 2009 unfortunately leaves a sense of reservation. This is actually linked to the second problem, namely that despite the relatively radical twists and turns the script offers in its concept, the film contains no downright radical genre scenes. Something like the opening shotgun entrance in Martyrs, the circular saw scene in Frontier(s), or the motorcycle finale in the Evil Dead remake. These problems are then what keep Us from five stars, because otherwise, like Get Out, it's really a breath of life into a moribund horror genre whose work with gradation, a dose of twists, and working with pop culture (using the Hands Across America initiative to make a point? FTW!) is something to be cherished. The last shot, with Minnie Riperton's "Les Fleurs", almost won that fifth star. (25.06.2019)

I'm almost beginning to think that Jordan Peele chooses the actors for the lead roles for their eyes, but it's also for their acting mastery. Lupita Nyong'o was perfect for the lead role, both for her better version and the darker one, which is truly terrifying. Jordan Peele then shows that he can also build scenes brilliantly to make them scary simply through their visuals. He is truly a horror talent. (21.06.2019)

CONTAINS SPOILERS. Jordan Peele is a god-forsaken racist. How else can you explain how a black family resists their raiders valiantly and a white family ends up being dismembered in a matter of seconds. Moreover, notice how the white girls (daughters) are depicted – scantily clad and notable for supporting the "white challenger girl" stereotype, while the black girl (daughter) was not depicted in even remotely this way (the only thing she had exposed for even a moment were her shoulders). Just as Jordan Peele managed to put a humorous spin on all the stereotypes in Get Out and put the theme of racism in a brilliantly satirical context, he desperately overstepped with Us. Sorry, but this movie is really, really racist. Only the black family can manage to handle everything, and compared to the decadent white people (who only drink, get plastic surgery, and have an indifferent attitude towards life), only the black family stays focused and disciplined enough to eventually murder all their opponents. I haven't been this pissed off watching a movie in a long time. Two measly stars for the solid technical aspects. (05.07.2019)