Jeoffrey

Dafür, dass die Prämisse der gesamten Serie über vertauschte Kinder wie aus einer unterdurchschnittlichen mexikanischen Telenovela wirkt, war ich ziemlich überrascht, wie intim und ab und an langweilige Romanze A Couple of Cuckoos ist. Der Humor hier schlitter scharf entlang der Grenze zur gewöhnlichen Dummheit, viele pseudo-dramatische Momente werden durch dumme Missverständnisse oder gewöhnliche Genreklischees aufgebaut. Ich konnte nicht einmal eine der drei Mädels in der Geschichte finden, die ich wirklich stark bejubeln konnte, und Umino selbst ist für mich ziemlich uninteressant, fade und unspektakulär. Seine Beziehung zu seiner Stiefschwester war schließlich am schlimmsten für mich. Die Serie versucht, sie als eine mögliche Lösung für das gesamte romantische Durcheinander darzustellen, aber ich glaube einfach nicht daran, und Sachi scheint mir eher wie ein nerviges Anhängsel als eine romantische Möglichkeit. Bei den anderen beiden Mädels sieht es schon etwas besser aus, man kann zumindest ein bisschen Chemie spüren, und ich verstehe, worauf die Autoren hier hinaus wollen, aber ich kann nicht sagen, dass es mich besonders begeistert oder dass ich es wirklich genossen hätte. Animationstechnisch gelungen und die Musik ist hörbar und versucht zumindest einen gewissen Eindruck zu erzeugen. Es gibt auch ein paar stärkere Momente, die jedoch nicht so bedeutsam sind, dass sie mich erschüttern oder großes Interesse wecken würden. Also insgesamt war das für mich ein typischer Durchlauf-Anime, den ich zwar bis zum Ende geschaut habe, aber nicht viel davon mitgenommen habe. In ein paar Tagen werde ich wahrscheinlich schon vergessen haben, dass ich ihn gesehen habe, und ob ich mir eine mögliche Fortsetzung anschauen würde, müsste ich länger darüber nachdenken. 4,5/10

Did you really think the second season would be as good as the first? Initially, I did, and I was really excited for it. I didn't even mind the change in the main character's voice actor since their voices are quite similar. That was the least of my concerns. What really got to me wasn't the terrible CGI for the monsters, which was the worst I've seen since the Great Goddess Mitama. Even with the awful CGI dragons and human-faced trees that looked like something from a mediocre PS2 game, the biggest issue wasn't the animation. The real problem was the lack of humor, lightness, and charm that the first season had. While there were some cool moments with Anos that I enjoyed and which reminded me why I love the main character, there were no memorable or over-the-top scenes like when Anos spun a castle like a top or defeated an opponent with the beat of his heart. The closest it got was in the final episode when Anos stomped seven times, but even that didn't quite hit the mark. What made it worse was the excessive amount of talking. It felt like the creators knew they wouldn’t get a second season initially, so they focused on making the main character look cool without much story exposition. But since the show became so popular, they crammed all the lore and story into the second season, resulting in a lot of boring dialogue that slowed down the pace significantly. I have nothing against complex stories and lore (I'm a big RPG player and DnD fan), but the way it was presented here felt unnecessary and dull. The story, while trying to be grand and convoluted, could always be summarized as "Nothing is ever what it seems, and everything turns out the way Anos wants." It's just a shame the journey to that conclusion wasn't as epic as the destination. This attempt at deep and complex fantasy made the show lose its fun and lightheartedness. What was once a simple and amusing story about an OP main character turned into an ultimate conflict with false demon lords, gods, and dragons. But the creators failed to make it engaging or enjoyable. Even when Anos says his iconic line, "Did you really think that..." it no longer brings a smile or anticipation for what's next. Considering all the production issues and delays (which also dampened my enthusiasm), the result is disappointing. A show I was eagerly awaiting became an average experience that I finished without much excitement. The first half was a 6/10, the second half barely a 5/10, so overall, it's a 5.5/10.

"This story is one that lightly describes the ordinary daily lives of the three Minami sisters. Please don’t expect too much from it." This interesting disclaimer at the start of each episode is both true and not quite accurate. The daily lives of the three Minami sisters are anything but ordinary, and it’s not just because of their unique personalities but also the quirky characters around them and their interactions. We meet the main characters, who are engaging enough on their own, but not quite compelling enough to carry the whole show. Fortunately, the supporting cast of classmates, friends, and neighbors add depth and humor, fitting perfectly into the mix and keeping things entertaining. Strangely enough, my favorite characters in this show about three sisters are actually two guys! The eccentric playboy Hosaka, with his wild fantasies and culinary skills, has a certain charm. Plus, he can cook, and he’s admirable for his dedication and the way he accepts love with all its potential complications. And then there’s “the big boss” Fujioka, whose earnest romantic efforts are endearing, even if he doesn’t have Hosaka’s style. Among the girls, Kana is my favorite — she’s pretty dense but full of energy, which I find appealing. But what really makes the first season of Minami-ke stand out and deserving of a higher rating is the diverse cast of characters and their relationships. Each episode managed to make me laugh at least once, even though I initially expected more comedy. The charming opening, the decent animation, and the well-crafted humor all add to its appeal. What truly hooked me, though, were the varied characters and their interactions. The show captures life’s little moments, often with a comedic twist, but never feels stupid or dull. I’m eager to see what happens next — will one of the girls fall in love and get a happy ending like Ninomiya-kun and Sensei, will Mako-chan ever revert to Makoto, will Hosaka’s fantasies ever come true, or will Kana get another kiss from somebody else than...? On to the next season to find out! 7.5/10